Best tarte maracuja juicy lip plumping gloss Dupes Under $25

Why Everyone's Obsessed with Tarte's Maracuja Juicy Lip Plumping Gloss

Tarte's Maracuja Juicy Lip Plumping Gloss has become a cult favorite for good reason. This $27 gloss delivers noticeable lip plumping without the intense tingle of traditional plumpers, thanks to its maracuja oil formula that hydrates while creating volume. The glossy finish looks incredibly juicy and healthy, while the comfortable wear time makes it perfect for daily use.

But let's be honest — $27 for a lip gloss stings, especially when you want multiple shades or need frequent repurchases. The good news? There are incredible dupes that deliver similar plumping effects and glossy finishes for a fraction of the price.

Top Drugstore Dupes That Actually Work

1. Morphe Lip Filter Hydroplump Soft Matte Lipstick - $10

Don't let the "soft matte" name fool you — this formula has a beautiful glossy finish that rivals Tarte's original. At $10, it's $17 cheaper than the Tarte version while delivering comparable plumping effects.

What makes it similar:

• Hydrating formula that plumps without irritation
• Long-wearing glossy finish
• Comfortable, non-sticky texture
• Wide shade range with similar undertones

Key differences:

• Slightly less intense plumping effect
• Takes about 30 seconds longer to achieve full plump
• Packaging is less luxurious but functional

The shade range is impressive, with options that match popular Tarte shades like "Birthday Suit" and "Rose." While the plumping isn't quite as dramatic, most users won't notice a significant difference in everyday wear.

2. e.l.f. Pure Bliss Glossy Lip Stain - $7

This budget-friendly option proves you don't need to spend big for plump, glossy lips. At just $7, it's $20 cheaper than Tarte while offering surprising quality and longevity.

What makes it similar:

• Glossy, juicy finish
• Hydrating formula with hyaluronic acid
• Comfortable wear without stickiness
• Beautiful color payoff

Key differences:

• Minimal plumping effect compared to Tarte
• Shorter wear time (4-5 hours vs 6-8 hours)
• Fewer shade options

While the plumping effect is subtle, the glossy finish and hydrating properties make this an excellent dupe for anyone who loves the look of Tarte's gloss but doesn't need intense plumping.

3. Maybelline Lifter Gloss - $8

A TikTok favorite that's earned its reputation through performance, not just hype. This $8 gloss delivers noticeable plumping with a formula that feels almost identical to Tarte's.

What makes it similar:

• Hyaluronic acid for plumping and hydration
• Non-sticky, comfortable formula
• Long-lasting glossy finish
• Easy application with doe-foot applicator

Key differences:

• Slightly tackier texture initially (settles quickly)
• Less premium packaging
• Fewer nude/MLBB shades

The "Heat" shade is a near-perfect dupe for Tarte's "Birthday Suit," while "Topaz" matches beautifully with Tarte's "Rose" shade. The plumping effect kicks in within minutes and lasts for hours.

4. NYX Professional Makeup Fat Oil Lip Drip - $9

This underrated gem offers superior hydration with a glossy finish that photographs beautifully. At $9, it's perfect for those who prioritize lip health alongside aesthetics.

What makes it similar:

• Oil-based formula for deep hydration
• Glossy, non-sticky finish
• Comfortable long wear
• Buildable color intensity

Key differences:

• More focused on hydration than plumping
• Slightly thinner consistency
• Takes longer to build up color intensity

The shade "01 Translucent" works beautifully as a clear gloss alternative, while the tinted shades provide that perfect "your lips but glossier" effect that makes Tarte's gloss so popular.

5. Essence What The Fake! Plumping Lip Filler - $4

The most budget-friendly option on our list doesn't compromise on quality. This $4 gloss delivers surprising plumping power and a glossy finish that rivals much more expensive options.

What makes it similar:

• Noticeable plumping effect within minutes
• Glossy, dimensional finish
• Non-irritating formula
• Lightweight, comfortable wear

Key differences:

• Smaller size (3.5ml vs 4.5ml)
• Limited shade range
• Less sophisticated packaging

Despite the low price point, the formula quality is impressive. The clear version works perfectly for enhancing your natural lip color, while the tinted options provide beautiful wash of color with plumping benefits.

Shade Matching Guide

Finding the perfect shade match is crucial for any successful dupe. Here are the closest matches to popular Tarte Maracuja shades:

For "Birthday Suit" fans:

• Morphe Lip Filter in "Trending"
• Maybelline Lifter Gloss in "Heat"

For "Rose" lovers:

• Morphe Lip Filter in "Socialite"
• Maybelline Lifter Gloss in "Topaz"

For clear gloss enthusiasts:

• Essence What The Fake! in "Clear"
• NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip in "Translucent"

Which Dupe Should You Choose?

For the closest overall experience: Morphe Lip Filter Hydroplump delivers the most similar plumping effect and glossy finish.

For maximum savings: Essence What The Fake! offers incredible value at just $4 without sacrificing quality.

For the best formula feel: Maybelline Lifter Gloss has the most similar texture and comfort level to the original.

For lip health focus: NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip prioritizes hydration while still delivering glossy results.

For beginners: e.l.f. Pure Bliss Glossy Lip Stain offers an affordable way to test the waters before investing in premium options.

Want to see even more alternatives? Check out the complete list of Tarte Maracuja Juicy Lip Plumping Gloss dupes for additional budget-friendly options.

The beauty of these dupes is that you can try multiple shades and formulas for less than the cost of one Tarte gloss. Whether you prioritize plumping power, longevity, or pure value, there's a perfect dupe waiting to give you those coveted glossy, plump lips without the premium price tag.