Best Dupes for Liquid Liner (2026)
We found 12 verified dupes for Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Liner, ranked by shade accuracy, formula overlap, and community consensus.
Anastasia Beverly Hillsvs
#1 Match
L'Oreal ParisDefiner Mechanical Waterproof Ultra-Fine Tip Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie Brush
Shade: Black$12.99Save $9.01
FA Safe
Shop on AmazonShade
Bonus
Formula
Excellent Match
100%Shade Match
0CommunityCommunity Mentions
Not yet buzzing
All 12 Dupes, Ranked
1L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisDefiner Mechanical Waterproof Ultra-Fine Tip Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie Brush
Shade: BlackL'Oreal Paris
Definer Mechanical Waterproof Ultra-Fine Tip Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie Brush
Shade: BlackFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
2L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisGrip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner
Shade: WhiteL'Oreal Paris
Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner
Shade: WhiteFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
3L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisHaute Couleur Kohl Pencil Eyeliner
Shade: 110 Black SilkL'Oreal Paris
Haute Couleur Kohl Pencil Eyeliner
Shade: 110 Black SilkFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
4L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisHaute Precision Liquid Eyeliner
Shade: 010 Black SilkL'Oreal Paris
Haute Precision Liquid Eyeliner
Shade: 010 Black SilkFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
5L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisMatte-Matic Liner
Shade: Ultra BlackL'Oreal Paris
Matte-Matic Liner
Shade: Ultra BlackFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
6L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisPrecision Liquid Eyeliner
Shade: Carbon BlackL'Oreal Paris
Precision Liquid Eyeliner
Shade: Carbon BlackFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
7L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisPro-Last Waterproof, Up to 24HR Pencil Eyeliner
Shade: BlackL'Oreal Paris
Pro-Last Waterproof, Up to 24HR Pencil Eyeliner
Shade: BlackFA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
8L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisSelf-Advancing Eyeliner
Shade: Carbon BlackL'Oreal Paris
Self-Advancing Eyeliner
Shade: Carbon BlackFA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
9L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisSmoldering Liner
Shade: BlackL'Oreal Paris
Smoldering Liner
Shade: BlackFA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
10L'Oreal ParisExcellent Match
L'Oreal ParisThe Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner
Shade: BlackL'Oreal Paris
The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner
Shade: BlackFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
11L'Oreal ParisGood Match
L'Oreal ParisLiquid Pencil Eyeliner
Shade: BlackL'Oreal Paris
Liquid Pencil Eyeliner
Shade: BlackFA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
12L'Oreal ParisGood Match
L'Oreal ParisNever Fail™ Eyeliner
Shade: Carbon BlackL'Oreal Paris
Never Fail™ Eyeliner
Shade: Carbon BlackFA Safe
Shade
Bonus
Formula
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
Community Verified
These dupes have been discussed across 0 Reddit threads and beauty forums. Scores reflect shade match accuracy, ingredient overlap, and real user sentiment.
Key Shared Ingredients
Ingredients found in both Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Liner and L'Oreal Paris Definer Mechanical Waterproof Ultra-Fine Tip Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie Brush