Best Dupes for PermaGel Ultra Lip Pencil (2026)
We found 10 verified dupes for Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Lip Pencil, ranked by shade accuracy, formula overlap, and community consensus.
The Original
Pat McGrath Labs
Pat McGrath LabsPermaGel Ultra Lip Pencil
$29.00FA Safe
vs
#1 Match
ColourPop
ColourPopLippie Pencil
$5.60Save $23.40
FA Safe
Shade
Excellent Match
Shop the original
Shop the dupe
97%Color Match
0CommunityCommunity Mentions
Not yet buzzing
All 10 Dupes, Ranked
1ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
2ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
3ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
4ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
5
Rare BeautyExcellent Match
Rare BeautyKind Words Matte Lip Liner
Rare Beauty
Kind Words Matte Lip Liner
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
6ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
7ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
8ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
9ColourPopExcellent Match
ColourPopLippie Pencil
ColourPop
Lippie Pencil
FA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
FA Safe
10
About-FaceExcellent Match
About-FaceMatte Fix Lip Pencil
About-Face
Matte Fix Lip Pencil
VeganCFFA Safe
Shade
Not yet buzzing
VeganCFFA Safe
Community Verified
These dupes have been discussed across 0 Reddit threads and beauty forums. Scores reflect color match accuracy, finish compatibility, and real user sentiment.